Breaking News

Unpacking floating of exchange rate by Zimbabwe

by Dr Mugano
22 February 2019 | 1046 Views
The Governor of the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) Dr Mangudya in his monetary policy statement liberalised the exchange rate that is, departing from the 1:1 position of the bond notes or real time gross settlement (RTGS) with the United States dollars. The purpose of this article is to unpack the rationale of this move and break down the implications of this move as well as showcasing areas that need to be carefully monitored by policy makers.

Conceptualising floating of Exchange Rate

By definition, when the exchange rate is floated it means that the price of domestic currency (that is the bond notes and RTGS) to foreign currency (that is the US dollar) which is the exchange rate will be determined through the invisible hand of demand and supply.

What it means is that the amount of foreign currency (that is supply) versus the amount of domestic currency chasing foreign currency (that is demand) will inform the exchange rate.

If we take the argument of the governor of the RBZ which point to the fact that there is $1,8 billion of active liquidity (which is used for transaction) in RTGS since about $8,2 billion is in treasury bills, savings bond and loans together with US$600 million, it would mean that mathematically within the framework of a floated exchange rate, there are chances that the market rate of local currency will be 1:3.

The Rationale of Floating the Exchange Rate

The rate of 1:1 undoubtedly created a number of problems ranging from creation of opportunities for rent seeking behaviour such as corruption and arbitrage opportunities emanating from distortions. By liberalising the exchange rate, the RBZ has wiped the possibilities of these ills since the distortions are removed.

In the same vein, the 1:1 presented competitiveness and viability challenges for exporters. For example, in the mining sector, those whose export receipts, that is, 50 percent of total exports, for example, were retained by the RBZ and liquidated at a rate of 1:1 in an environment where the parallel market rate was 1:3.2 was not making any economic sense. By floating the change rate, the competitiveness of the exporting sector is expected to significantly improve.

As expected in international finance, a fixed exchange arrangement repels foreign direct investment as well as inflows of remittances. One therefore hopes this new move will give a positive impetus as we drive to attract investors.

At a rate of 1:1 Government was certainly at a disadvantage when it comes to collection of customs revenue because the cost of imports in US dollar were accounted for at a rate of 1:1 thereby prejudicing Government of fiscal revenue. Under this new arrangement one expect to see duties being calculated using the prevailing exchange rate. This is expected to drive fiscal revenue upwards.

Complications in accounting, for listed companies where a firm has to adhere to basic things like compliance with law and in this case official exchange rate kicks in, it was not possible to present financial report using the parallel market rates but one had to stick to the official rate of 1:1. This situation created a false impression on the real value of the company. Now this new arrangement makes it easier for the firms to showcase the true value of the net worth of the firms, for example.

Areas which Requires  Attention by Policy Makers

Like any policy, there are always possible areas which require consistent monitoring with a view of dealing with likely challenges which may arise. For consistency, it is fair that I admit that I was very pessimistic about floating the exchange rate regardless of the benefits which are explained in the rationale above. My reservations were centred on legal, shortage of foreign exchange and inflationary pressures which may ensue.

Legal, in as much as I am not a lawyer, I still want to appreciate what will happen to the debts which are owed by Government and the generality of the population, which are denominated in the US dollar.

For example, the Government of Zimbabwe took over RBZ debt as well as some debts of state owned enterprises which are denominated in US dollar and these debts are in billions of dollars. The same can be said by households who acquired loans in US dollar and have contracts in US dollar. At a rate of 1:1, in my view, there was no confusion with regards to settlement of debts because the bond/RTGS was equivalent to US dollar.

Whilst I have no doubt that the policy makers have enough ammunition at their disposal to deal with this issue, I am of the view that explanations must be well articulated and fair guarantees must be put in place so that no one loses out on this issue.

The Governor argued that the transactional liquidity in RTGS is $1.8 billion, which I agree with. This is a reasonably low amount which can guarantee us comfort that the rate can play around 1:3. The concern which arises here is what will happen if treasury bills which constitute the lion share of the $8.8 billion matures? The question which arises where is that will these TBs be liquidated or Government will roll them over?




Liquidating the TBs will definitely increase money supply and therefore put pressure on the exchange rate to rise.

If Government takes a position of rolling them over one would like to understand the implications of such move on the viability of the companies who were anticipating to finance their cash flows on the back of the maturity of the TBs.

One way of going around this puzzle is to work on building foreign currency reserves from retained export earnings by RBZ as well as driving US dollar through provision of attractive investment vehicles to the diaspora, attract investments and promote exports.

This issue of TBs and US dollar liquidity enhancement requires serious policy attention.

One of the key issues which were raised in the policy statement by the Governor relates to mobilisation of lines of credit to guarantee a reasonable exchange rate. This is good. However, over and above the lines of credit mobilisation, there is need for the RBZ to come up with a framework which will see efficient accounting and use of foreign currency.

It boggles the mind when one consider the fact that annually the country receives around $6 billion in exports, lines of credits, diaspora remittances and foreign direct investment but struggles to meet key imports requirements. Rather, 84 percent of the total foreign currency earning is wasted through imports of useless things like tooth picks, pampers, chewing gums, agricultural produce, etc.

From a policy perspective, within the framework of the transitional stabilisation programme, Government must work with the RBZ to close these loopholes with a view of saving foreign currency.

Lastly, in view of the floating of the exchange rate after the budget statement has been done and dusted one would like to understand how the Minister of Finance is going to deal with his budget especially taking into account that this move has far reaching implication on the budget, that is, expenditure and revenue?

What does it mean for the ordinary Zimbabwean

At the heart of the ordinary Zimbabweans is the questions as what will happen to their savings and of course the cost of living.

It is undeniable that the floating of the exchange rate will result in erosion of savings and pensions of the ordinary Zimbabweans. For instance, if one individual had made investments in a savings account and at one point the monies had accrued to $100 000 at a rate of 1:1. Or consider one who deposited $100,000 real dollars eight years ago and now bring in the liberalised exchange of 1:4 into account one will see that the real value of the $100 000 today is now US$25 000. The same observation applies to pensioners. This was again one of my reservations on floating. With this experience where economic agents have lost their pension twice in 10 years period will discourage savings which are key for driving investment and economic growth.

Prices and wages spiral, the move to liberalise exchange rate will definitely result in incessant calls for adjustment of wages and salaries across of sectors including Government.

Any adjustment of wages and salaries will result in price increases in the short term. In the same vein, suppliers of utilities such as water and electricity and even rates like toll gates who haven't adjusted their prices under the new exchange rate will be forced to review their prices upwards.

What is the Overall Outlook

Notwithstanding the possible setbacks which are addressed in the previous sections above, after considering the guarantees put in place by the Governor, there is hope that we can now have a better economic outlook. However, in order to continue to sustain this positive economic outlook, it is important that the issues I raised which requires policy considerations are attended to.

Dr Mugano (Ph.D) is an Author and Expert in Trade and International Finance. He has successfully supervised four Doctorate candidates in the field of Trade and International finance, published over twenty – five articles and book chapters in peer reviewed journals. He is a Research Associate at Nelson Mandela University, Registrar at Zimbabwe Ezekiel Guti University and Director at Africa Economic Development Strategies. Feedback: Cell: +263 772 541 209. Email: gmugano@gmail.com

Exchange Floating Forex


Disclaimer:
All articles and letters published on Bulawayo24 have been independently written by members of Bulawayo24's community. The views of users published on Bulawayo24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Bulawayo24. Bulawayo24 editors also reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received.

Source: businessweekly

Comments

Latest News

Rocks from mountain crush huts in Zimbabwe

by City Press | 24 March 2019 | 2253 Views

'Tax reforms to rescue debt-distressed Zimbabwe'

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 653 Views

Afreximbank grants Zimbabwe interbank forex trade loan

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 734 Views

Zimbabwe volcano fears - The Civil Protection Department (CPD) in Masv...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 2854 Views

Mnangagwa goes Biblical: 'Zimbabwe accepts will of God'

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 1048 Views

Open letter to President Mnangagwa

by Viniel Deredza | 24 March 2019 | 873 Views

Warriors ease into Afcon finals

by SuperSport | 24 March 2019 | 568 Views

Rights Commission finalising probe into Zimbabwe army crackdown - THE ...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 154 Views

3 lawyers banned from practising - THREE lawyers have been banned from...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 592 Views

Jabulani Sibanda to bounce back?

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 908 Views

Questions over Mnangagwa's choice of advisors - ON three occasions, Pr...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 244 Views

Potraz board okays tariff increases

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 212 Views

Horror Cyclone destruction trail unravels - THE human toll of Cyclone ...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 134 Views

LIVE: Zimbabwe vs Congo Brazzaville

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 3493 Views

Zimbabwe debt should be audited - ZIMBABWE should not rush to pay its ...

by John Kachembere | 24 March 2019 | 811 Views

Zimbabwean couple hijacked in Durban, wife missing since Monday - A Zi...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 3738 Views

Mnangagwa's days numbered

by Staff repo | 24 March 2019 | 8041 Views

Zimbabwean man dies during sex with SA mistress - A  67- year-old...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 3615 Views

Zimbabwean company donates laptops to needy SA varsity students - Zoro...

by African News Agency (ANA) | 24 March 2019 | 1037 Views

Gweru prophet sets up school of spiritual gifts - Gweru-born Prophet G...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 487 Views

Potraz brings toll free platforms to rural folk

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 162 Views

Mnangagwa pledges support for Gukurahundi victims

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 409 Views

Zimbabwe banks must support the interbank trading - THE interbank mark...

by Andrew Lampard | 24 March 2019 | 262 Views

Robbing the poor in the name of patriotism - The post-Robert Mugabe ad...

by Tawanda Majoni | 24 March 2019 | 221 Views

'Using Air Zimbabwe will pose logistical problems for Mnangagwa' - Dep...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 416 Views

Entertainment

Andy Muridzo promises new album

by Simbarashe Sithole | 18 March 2019 | 308 Views

Kwejani band is back! - AFTER an eight-year hiatus, Victoria Falls' su...

by Staff reporter | 13 March 2019 | 1189 Views

Moyo revives Pantsula genre

by Staff reporter | 10 March 2019 | 464 Views

Majaivana's sad farewell

by Bruce Ndlovu | 10 March 2019 | 6756 Views

Nceku shifts base to SA

by Staff reporter | 09 March 2019 | 826 Views

Baba Harare abandoned by band members - Jit musician, Baba Harare has ...

by Staff reporter | 04 March 2019 | 2050 Views

Winky D pays the price

by Staff reporter | 03 March 2019 | 5517 Views
iBlog

Mobile Spy Software Maker Mspy Hacked

mspy, the makers of a software-as-a-service product that claims to help more than two million people spy on the mobile devices of their kids and partners, to have been massively hacked. a public relations pitch from mspy to krebsonsecurity in march ... Read More
SecNews 17 May 2015 ago

Apple Watch Teardown Reveals Unique Hardware And Replaceable Parts

The apple watch may not be fine jewelry, but bill detwiler cracks it open and shows you why he thinks it's a fine piece of tech. the apple watch may be beautiful on the outside, but how about on the inside? in this cracking open installment, we go in... Read More
Sergey 11 June 2015 ago