Breaking News

Zimbabweans disillusioned with the 'new dispensation'

by Ray Matikinye
22 February 2019 | 204 Views
MORE than a year ago events touted as an unfolding new beginning in this Southern African nation raised public hope. The Zimbabwean "benign" coup in November 2017 must be counted among the greatest of surprises for the spike in, restlessness it has spawned. The events somewhat mimicked Mikhail Gorbachev-style glasnost and perestroika rolled in one.

But true to form, history has lived up to its expectation, never found wanting in repeating itself in one form or another no matter how long it might take.

In decades since 1980 leading up to November 2017, virtually no political analyst or aspiring politician foresaw the impending collapse of the Robert Mugabe-led regime alongside its one-party dictatorship; state-controlled economy, and the ruling Zanu-PF's monolithic stranglehold over citizens' social architecture.

Save for a clutch of exceptions, Zimbabwe's splintered opposition and single-issue lobbyists did not foresee a monumental economic slide in the aftermath of that collapse.

When Emmerson Mnangagwa and his cohort securocrats became overly chagrined by former First Lady Grace Mugabe's truculent daring of feuding factions in the ruling party, none of his contemporaries anticipated their reaction would trigger a deep-seated socio-economic crisis.

No one thought the frail, power besotted nonagenarian former school teacher, Mugabe — in unbridled power since 1987 when he assumed the executive presidency — would loosen his grip on power, at least not anytime soon and that his ignoble fall portended the onset of a crippling economic meltdown.

The failure by analysts and social commentators to anticipate the Mugabe administration's collapse may partly be attributed to public indoctrination steeped in exaggerating his regime's stability and legitimacy. Others who could hardly be considered as indisposed to dictatorship were just as puzzled by his regime's dramatic demise.

But one percipient author though, in his book aptly titled Zimbabwe – A Revolution that Lost its Way, somewhat foresaw the demise of Mugabe's toxic rule as did one of Mugabe's contemporaries, Eddison Zvobgo, who once cautioned of the dangers of turning noble reform processes into "a racial enterprise".

Zvobgo was referring to the chaotic, often violent agrarian reform which, alongside a raft of other hostile and out-of-sync economic policies, is credited with spawning a spectacular economic meltdown.

Yet even after the "soft coup", the assumption that Zimbabwe would continue in its current state, or at most that it would eventually begin a long, drawn-out decline fuelled by disputed election outcomes seemed just as unpredictable. There is a slew of similarities between Zimbabwe under the so-called "new dispensation" and the Soviet Union under Gorbachev and his legendary glasnost and perestroika.

Picture this and wonder whether Mnangagwa's putsch was cloned from a Gorbachev prototype which prompted the famed glasnost and perestroika.

In the Soviet Union the standard of living was much lower than in most of Eastern Europe, and most of other countries in the West. Shortages, basic commodity rationing, long queues in stores, and acute poverty were endemic.

Zimbabwe has been facing foreign currency shortages that have torched a socio-economic crisis with supplies of fuel, basic commodities and medical drugs drying up. Like the Soviet Union, Zimbabwe has witnessed far greater calamities and coped without sacrificing an iota of the state's grip on society and economy, much less surrendering it. But the calamities here seem to have reached a fresh pitch attributed to endless political bungling, endemic economic mismanagement fuelled by corruption among the elite and disputed elections.

The rapidly advancing economic crisis appears underpinned by potential investors' reluctance to take the gamble and loosen their purses and inject critical impetus to economic recovery in the aftermath of state-induced post-election violence that left seven unarmed civilians dead.

For a country that has a long history of state-sponsored violence, the controversial post-plebiscite ballot counting raised the bridge ahead of what might have been viewed as a clearer path towards international acceptance and investor confidence. The post-election deaths took the wind out of the little prospects of sprucing up the pariah status Zimbabwe has long endured.

Stagnation during the ancien regime under Mugabe was obvious and worrisome. But from the regime's point of view, the political circumstances were even less troublesome after decades of relentless suppression of political opposition, through capricious legislation that hamstrung virtually all prominent antagonists for democracy to thrive. Nothing seems to have changed.

There seemed to be other signs Mnangagwa's glasnost and perestroika of a pre-putsch crisis, including other traditionally assigned causes of state failure — external pressure often cited by the ruling Zanu-PF elite as punitive illegal sanctions imposed by the West and its allies for pervasive human rights abuses. Between November 2017 and now, the state and its economic system have evidently begun to totter towards the brink.

The latest Zimbabwean revolution, akin to Gorbachev's glasnost and perestroika, extended well beyond the necessity to correct the economic malaise or make the international environment more benign.

The core of Mnangagwa's enterprise is undeniably idealistic:

He wants to build a more modern Zimbabwe — a middle income economy as his trite mantra claims. For though economic betterment instantly became his government's clarion call, there is little doubt that Mnangagwa and his ruling clique set out to tinker with uprooting corruption rather than confront economic wrongs head-on.

One of the reasons trotted out for the benign putsch was to weed out a corrupt cabal behind Zimbabwe's moribund economy through corrupt practices among the elite beholden to Mugabe.

It still remains an insurmountable hurdle to overcome even though a facade is often put up that weeding out corruption among the elite is a priority.

Only a small part of the oligarchy has been prosecuted, much to the nettling disdain among the citizenry who thought putsch leaders had hit the ground running.

Most of what the architects of the putsch said publicly in the early days now seems no more than an expression of their sorrow over the decline and corrosive effects of the Mugabe regime's past. For the putschists much of it was the same scenario Gorbachev faced in 1985.

It was the beginning of a desperate search for answers to the big questions with which every great revolution starts: What is a good, dignified life? What constitutes a just social and economic order? What is a decent and legitimate state? What should such a state's relationship with civil society be? The Soviet ruling elite, like the leaders of the "soft coup", initially purported to do, was to espouse pragmatism and face reality, as Gorbachev's prime minister, Nikolai Ryzhkov, succinctly put it: "We stole from ourselves, took and gave bribes, lied in the reports, in newspapers, from high podiums, wallowed in our lies, hung medals on one another. And all of this — from top to bottom and from bottom to top".

These are hallmarks of Zimbabwe's ills, too stubborn to wash.

Former Soviet foreign minister Eduard Shevardnadze was just as pained by ubiquitous lawlessness and corruption and told Gorbachev: "Everything is rotten. It has to be changed."

One can easily draw similarities between Gorbachev and Mnangagwa. The latter's initial narrative seemed cloned from the Gorbachev prototype.

"A new work ethic is taking shape in the country," Gorbachev told the central committee at the January 1987 meeting where he declared glasnost — openness — and democratisation to be the foundation of his perestroika, or restructuring, of Soviet society. "A re-appraisal of values and their creative rethinking is underway."

Zimbabweans mistakenly felt the ideals of a new dispensation had come at an ideal time amid their increasing indignation at corruption, brazen thievery, lies, and the obstacles in the way of honest work. Anticipations of "substantive" changes were in the air.

Mnangagwa is still a troubadour of the mantra of a new dispensation even though ordinary people seem not to derive any joy from that rhetoric. And that is where the similarities with Gorbachev's perestroika and glasnost end.

It might be instructive for Zimbabweans to come to terms with the fact that it may be enough just to bring down the ancien regime, but not to overcome in one fell swoop, a deep-seated authoritarian national political culture. The roots of the democratic institutions spawned by morally charged revolutions may prove too shallow to sustain a functioning democracy in a society with precious little tradition of openness.

More than a year now, Zimbabweans still wonder if a revolution from past malpractices has occurred. Most seem to regret their participation in an event that rallied them onto the streets and seem to think that they have clapped their hands too early.

Their frustrations found expression in January this year in a national shutdown triggered by Mnangagwa's announcement of a hefty price hike in fuel prices that spawned nationwide looting, resulting in further civilian deaths when security forced opened fired on rioters, killing 16 and injuring scores of others in an unprecedented crackdown.

Government's heavy-handed reaction battened down international belief that nothing much had changed regarding its blighted record of human rights abuse.

Ray Matikinye

Zimbabweans Dillussioned Mnangagwa

All articles and letters published on Bulawayo24 have been independently written by members of Bulawayo24's community. The views of users published on Bulawayo24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Bulawayo24. Bulawayo24 editors also reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received.

Source: the independent


Latest News

Rocks from mountain crush huts in Zimbabwe

by City Press | 24 March 2019 | 2326 Views

'Tax reforms to rescue debt-distressed Zimbabwe'

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 673 Views

Afreximbank grants Zimbabwe interbank forex trade loan

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 754 Views

Zimbabwe volcano fears - The Civil Protection Department (CPD) in Masv...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 2914 Views

Mnangagwa goes Biblical: 'Zimbabwe accepts will of God'

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 1064 Views

Open letter to President Mnangagwa

by Viniel Deredza | 24 March 2019 | 889 Views

Warriors ease into Afcon finals

by SuperSport | 24 March 2019 | 574 Views

Rights Commission finalising probe into Zimbabwe army crackdown - THE ...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 159 Views

3 lawyers banned from practising - THREE lawyers have been banned from...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 609 Views

Jabulani Sibanda to bounce back?

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 940 Views

Questions over Mnangagwa's choice of advisors - ON three occasions, Pr...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 248 Views

Potraz board okays tariff increases

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 219 Views

Horror Cyclone destruction trail unravels - THE human toll of Cyclone ...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 141 Views

LIVE: Zimbabwe vs Congo Brazzaville

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 3504 Views

Zimbabwe debt should be audited - ZIMBABWE should not rush to pay its ...

by John Kachembere | 24 March 2019 | 813 Views

Zimbabwean couple hijacked in Durban, wife missing since Monday - A Zi...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 3743 Views

Mnangagwa's days numbered

by Staff repo | 24 March 2019 | 8062 Views

Zimbabwean man dies during sex with SA mistress - A  67- year-old...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 3633 Views

Zimbabwean company donates laptops to needy SA varsity students - Zoro...

by African News Agency (ANA) | 24 March 2019 | 1039 Views

Gweru prophet sets up school of spiritual gifts - Gweru-born Prophet G...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 489 Views

Potraz brings toll free platforms to rural folk

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 163 Views

Mnangagwa pledges support for Gukurahundi victims

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 415 Views

Zimbabwe banks must support the interbank trading - THE interbank mark...

by Andrew Lampard | 24 March 2019 | 262 Views

Robbing the poor in the name of patriotism - The post-Robert Mugabe ad...

by Tawanda Majoni | 24 March 2019 | 223 Views

'Using Air Zimbabwe will pose logistical problems for Mnangagwa' - Dep...

by Staff reporter | 24 March 2019 | 420 Views


Andy Muridzo promises new album

by Simbarashe Sithole | 18 March 2019 | 308 Views

Kwejani band is back! - AFTER an eight-year hiatus, Victoria Falls' su...

by Staff reporter | 13 March 2019 | 1189 Views

Moyo revives Pantsula genre

by Staff reporter | 10 March 2019 | 464 Views

Majaivana's sad farewell

by Bruce Ndlovu | 10 March 2019 | 6757 Views

Nceku shifts base to SA

by Staff reporter | 09 March 2019 | 827 Views

Baba Harare abandoned by band members - Jit musician, Baba Harare has ...

by Staff reporter | 04 March 2019 | 2050 Views

Winky D pays the price

by Staff reporter | 03 March 2019 | 5517 Views

Hp Omen 15-5116tx – The Next Generation Gaming Laptop

the hp omen 15-5116tx is being targeted at the performance hungry gamers. it comes in a single variant boasting an eye-catching attractive design. the notebook offers a slim, lightweight chassis and appears like a piece of art than an actual gaming... Read More
Sergey 11 June 2015 ago

Greatsoftline For All Of Your Software Needs

coupon and promo codes: greatsoftline for all of your software needswhile some online sellers have promotional services that reduce the overall amount you spent, others do not .you need to be on the lookout for the best outlets in order to chase th... Read More
ITnews 25 February 2015 ago