Breaking News

Sadc, EU positions on Zimbabwe: Attempting an end of history

by Takura Zhangazha
21 February 2019 | 917 Views
Last week, there were two very important statements issued on Zimbabwe by two very important inter-State political bodies. The first of these statements and closer to home was issued by the Southern African Development Community(Sadc) chairperson, Namibia President Hage Geinjob.

In the statement, Geinjob condemned recent political violence in Zimbabwe without putting the blame on government or the opposition. But more significantly, he called for the removal of sanctions on Zimbabwe, wherein he said (to quote him at length): "The Sadc Heads and State and government further noted that the governments efforts to transform the economy and bring about prosperity to the people of Zimbabwe are negatively affected by the illegal sanctions that were imposed on the country since early 2000.
Sadc expresses its solidarity with the government and people of the Republic of Zimbabwe and calls upon the international community to unconditionally lift all sanctions imposed on the country."

It was a statement that got an angry reaction from Zimbabwe's opposition and some civil society organisations and activists. With some unfortunately referring to the Sadc acronym as standing for a "Southern African Dictators Club".

Not more than a week later the European Parliament (EP) made public its resolutions and recommendations to its executive arm, the European Commission (EC) on Zimbabwe.

In it the EP condemned political violence, the Internet shutdown and to quote it at length: "Reminds the government of Zimbabwe that the support of the European Union and its member States in the context of the Cotonou Agreement and for trade, development and economic assistance, is conditional on its respecting the rule of law and the international convention and treaties to which it is party: Recalls that long-term support hinges on comprehensive reforms rather than mere promises; calls for European engagement with Zimbabwe to be value-driven and firm in its positioning towards the Zimbabwean authorities."

As indicated in the firm language used in the resolutions, the Zimbabwean government's attempts at re-engagement for reprieve with the EU has suffered a severe setback. And the reaction from pro-ruling Zanu-PF party activists has been to quite literally blame the opposition for this firm stance by the EP.

Both the State-controlled and private mainstream media in what is now their expected partisan political output also reflected the views of their editorial and political preferences.

But as always critical context matters. That the positions of Sadc and the EP differ is very clear. The motives for the same are however not so apparent.

Sadc's position appears to be predicated on a Pan-Africanism that is wary of interference in the domestic affairs of a member State. Not only by itself, but also more significantly by international organisations that it has historically been suspicious of their intentions. I mention history here because Sadc is not just a latter day "treaty organisation". It is a relatively historically organic one.

Largely etched from the anti-colonial and liberation struggle focused Frontline States (FLS) (initially comprised of Zambia, Tanzania and Botswana. Mozambique and Angola joined the group upon their attainment of independence to be followed by Zimbabwe in 1980).

The FLS were to then establish the Southern African Development Co-ordinating Conference, which also then spawned the now existent Sadc.

In light of this, whichever way one looks at it, the contemporary Sadc and a majority of its member States are strongly informed by an anti-imperialist/colonialism ethos.

A lot of us may consider the latter to be outdated and an excuse for protecting "dictators", but regardless it remains an historical reality that cannot be wished away.

It is a reality that makes Sadc one of the strongest regional political blocs in the world– minus the firepower of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (Nato).

The EU's position is, however, predicated on an understanding of global universalism, as well as the strength of its placement in global politics and the attendant economics/neoliberalism.

And the historicity of it is again largely based on the fact that it is a union comprised of former colonial hegemons in Africa with vested interests beyond the political. It is an historical fact that we cannot run away from even if we wanted to.

Where we juxtapose these two positions from the EU and Sadc, we would do well to keep in mind how the two bodies potentially view each other. Not that there was antipathy toward the global interaction and agreements on universal human values, but more because of the specificities of regional histories and contexts. Particularly, in the case of southern Africa.

It is, therefore, imperative that lobby and advocacy activities on Zimbabwe always keeps this in mind.

As it did, for example, in 2007 when Sadc intervened directly in Zimbabwe under the chairpersonship of then Tanzania President Jakaya Kikwete who then appointed then South Africa President Thabo Mbeki as the mediator on the Zimbabwean question(s).

The inclusive government that stemmed therefrom should have moved the country forward, but it didn't. Not least because of continued disputations over the land question that it failed to resolve. And that the current Zimbabwean government considers to be final.

What then becomes interesting is the possibility that there is an evident desire on the part of Sadc and the EU to move away from the past.

In respect of the former, it is to take Zimbabwe to a post-former President Robert Mugabe era while not negating or directly appearing to be compromising on issues to do with sovereignty and of course, land.

The latter, however, may have queries with the current government as to its failure to move away from Mugabe era not only in respect to human rights but also and probably more importantly to property (land) rights.

In both however, if we look closely, we see an attempt to move on or move back.

In any case, as has been now proven, history does not end.

Takura Zhangazha writes in his personal capacity (

Takura Zhangazha EU Sadc

All articles and letters published on Bulawayo24 have been independently written by members of Bulawayo24's community. The views of users published on Bulawayo24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Bulawayo24. Bulawayo24 editors also reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received.

Source: newsday


Latest News

Making things simple

by ZimVigil | 19 May 2019 | 441 Views

Misheck Velaphi Ncube Obituary: Connecting the Dots - Misheck Velaphi ...

by Iphithule Maphosa | 19 May 2019 | 305 Views

'Mnangagwa must convene inclusive national dialogue' - reward for rigg...

by Nomusa Garikai | 19 May 2019 | 387 Views

Embarrassing Zanu-PF Bulawayo election results nullified - Cephas Ncub...

by Methusi Ncube | 19 May 2019 | 1532 Views

Joshua Nkomo Scholarship 2019 successful candidates - full list

by Staff reporter | 19 May 2019 | 1413 Views

Zimbabwe warns visitors of fake visa websites

by Staff reporter | 19 May 2019 | 401 Views

Khupe goes after Chamisa's 'assets'

by Staff reporter | 19 May 2019 | 2766 Views

WATCH: Donkey cart driver demonstrates pro parking skills - No mirrors...

by Staff reporter | 19 May 2019 | 835 Views

Chihuri faces deportation from Malawi

by Staff reporter | 19 May 2019 | 2269 Views

Fake Canadian immigration scams targeting Zimbabweans

by Staff reporter | 19 May 2019 | 1448 Views

WATCH: Chamisa addresses Chiredzi residents

by Mandla Ndlovu | 19 May 2019 | 5957 Views

'It is my singular honour to launch Political Dialogue' - yes, and nat...

by Patrick Guramatunhu | 19 May 2019 | 1610 Views

Villager slapped to death - A BUHERA man died on the spot after being ...

by Staff reporter | 19 May 2019 | 2632 Views

'Hands off flea markets' ZANU PF Youth leader warns

by Pupurai Togarepi | 19 May 2019 | 3585 Views

'Americans sponsor violence in Zimbabwe'

by Mandla Ndlovu | 19 May 2019 | 5232 Views

Cocospy Review: Best mobile Spy App for parents and employers

by Staff Writer | 19 May 2019 | 1207 Views

State of the Zimbabwe economy - Mthuli Ncube report

by Mthuli Ncube | 19 May 2019 | 5401 Views

Same crime two laws, what a shame!

by Munya Shumba | 19 May 2019 | 1910 Views

ANC (South Africa) and Gukurahundi

by Sihle Ndlovu | 19 May 2019 | 1232 Views

Rigging fears hit Chamisa's MDC congress

by Staff reporter | 19 May 2019 | 1618 Views

MDC secretary-general hopefuls speak out

by Staff reporter | 19 May 2019 | 799 Views

Mnangagwa wants a critical friend, not more praise worshippers

by Zifiso Masiye | 19 May 2019 | 691 Views

Secret payments to Nikuv exposed

by Staff reporter | 19 May 2019 | 1867 Views

Chief Ndiweni remains defiant

by Staff reporter | 19 May 2019 | 1151 Views

Gay teacher lands scholarship

by Staff reporter | 19 May 2019 | 1141 Views

Ex Zanu-PF band leader drops Chamisa single

by Staff reporter | 19 May 2019 | 1520 Views


Nigerian to play Mugabe role in forthcoming movie

by Staff reporter | 18 May 2019 | 1914 Views

Malunga quits sex

by Staff reporter | 15 May 2019 | 6931 Views

I didn't ride on Tuku's fame, says Selmor

by Staff reporter | 14 May 2019 | 2104 Views

Tsholotsho girl shines in SA - DYNAMITE comes in small packages is the...

by Staff reporter | 13 May 2019 | 2377 Views

Jah Prayzah ditches anything associated with Mnangagwa's army

by Staff reporter | 12 May 2019 | 4218 Views

The rising popularity of Maskandi artists in Bulawayo

by Staff reporter | 12 May 2019 | 1955 Views

WATCH: Oliver Mtukudzi's widow singing Paunapopo

by Mandla Ndlovu | 01 May 2019 | 22994 Views

Disappointing first episode for Our Perfect Wedding Zimbabwe - PERHAPS...

by Staff reporter | 01 May 2019 | 1814 Views

Mobile Spy Software Maker Mspy Hacked

mspy, the makers of a software-as-a-service product that claims to help more than two million people spy on the mobile devices of their kids and partners, to have been massively hacked. a public relations pitch from mspy to krebsonsecurity in march ... Read More
SecNews 17 May 2015 ago

Tb Joshua Worst Enemy Angelique Tonge Exposed

About two years ago, we came out emphatically about those behind the t.b joshua watch. many were those who thought we were framing innocent people up or on a witch hunt. some events have vindicated us and the cat is out of the bag. it is said that no... Read More
pointblank 01 May 2015 ago