Breaking News

You shall not crucify Zimbabwe on a cross of bond notes

by Colls Ndlovu
03 November 2018 | 3310 Views
RECENT dramatic events arising from allegations that certain officials of the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) have been involved in currency malfeasance using the bond note as their lever to execute transactions that prejudiced the people of Zimbabwe in general and the economy in particular, have triggered the question of central bank independence among Zimbabweans of different ideological stripes.

The fact that the said officials were subsequently summarily suspended by the RBZ pending an investigation into their alleged activities made a bad situation worse insofar as the question of the independence of a central bank is concerned. Members of the general public have long been suspicious that something is not kosher with their central bank, especially given its previous duplicitous role in excessively printing the Zimbabwe dollar, removal of zeros, causing hyperinflation that reached trillions and ultimately reduced Zimbabweans into paupers.

When the bond note was formally introduced in November 2016, allegedly to incentivise exporters, the public was even more suspicious that the central bank was up to something sinister. Some observers and analysts argued that the central bank was pursuing snake-oil economics and currency options.

In the United States, way back in 1896, William Jennings Bryan memorably wailed: "… You shall not crucify mankind upon a cross of gold." He was railing against the US Federal Reserve's religious belief on the virtues of the gold standard monetary system. Bryan was arguing for the adoption of silver as an additional monetary instrument. Borrowing Bryan's quote above, Zimbabweans can rail against their own central bank (that is, the RBZ): "You shall not crucify Zimbabweans upon a cross of bond notes."

The foregoing is reflective of the divisive nature of money in a given society. Money is a lubricant that oils the wheels of the economy. Its ability to serve as a store of value and consequently wealth, makes it a central point of reference whenever a society undergoes financial strife. Ordinary Zimbabweans have a right to subject their central bank to never-ending scrutiny.

Within the context of Zimbabwe, the RBZ is a magnet for many of the tensions and social strife that afflict the country. Given its ability to manipulate the currency and therefore affect and influence the distribution of wealth in the country, it is to be expected that the RBZ should be a subject of endless perceptions and misperceptions — hardly an inconsequential issue.

Disoriented by the dramatic collapse of their country's financial system, especially since the spectacular rise of the hyperinflation of 2008 and the subsequent demonitisation of the Zimbabwe dollar, Zimbabweans have generally become suspicious of their central bank with some arguing that it is capable of destabilising the economy either willingly or unwittingly.

The people's negative views about the RBZ somewhat waxed and waned pursuant to the adoption of the multi-currency system in 2009 through to October 2016. But the suspicion was revived in November 2016 when the RBZ introduced the bond note. There was a widespread sentiment that the bond note was in fact the Zim dollar in camouflage.

Against the backdrop of the foregoing, the central question which arises relates to the so-called independence of a central bank.

A central bank is an instrumentality of the government. It is a government agency, just like any other parastatal, except that it enjoys a degree of independence as prescribed by the constitution. However, the independence of a central bank must be understood to be within but not outside of government. In other words, while the RBZ may enjoy intra-governmental independence, it cannot, at the same time, enjoy independence outside of government. From outside of government, the RBZ is viewed as part of government and therefore not independent of government.

This is unlike in the auditing profession where the independence of an external auditor is sacred and supreme. An external auditor is not only supposed to be independent, but must be seen to be so in fact and in appearance. However, the position is different with internal auditors. Internal auditors draw monthly salaries from a company and are, in fact, full-time employees of that company. Internal auditors (as distinct from external auditors) can be said to be independent within a company, but an outsider perceives them to be part of that company and therefore not independent.

The same analogy applies to the RBZ. The RBZ might be independent within government circles, but ordinary folks out there consider it to be part and parcel of government and hence not independent. It therefore follows that its actions, whether good or bad, are viewed as actions of the Zimbabwean government. With this thin line of independence, of course there is a risk of short-term political considerations, especially during election time, being used by political classes to push an agenda which might prejudice the long-term welfare of the people.

The semblance of immunity that the RBZ used to enjoy prior to the devastating hyperinflation of 2008 ended abruptly when the people's savings were wiped out with the demonitisation of the Zim dollar. Thereafter, the RBZ has been viewed as being part of the financial problem rather than a solution.

The independence of a central bank is therefore conditional upon that central bank meeting the expectations of ordinary citizens through pursuing policies that are broadly acceptable to Zimbabweans and their political representatives in parliament.

It cannot be acceptable in a democratic society that a group of unaccountable and unelected individuals can sit secretly behind closed doors and make decisions that affect ordinary Zimbabweans in such a big way like adopting the bond note and want to remain immune to criticism in the convenient name of central bank independence without being open to full public scrutiny. In other words, independence cannot be used by central banks as a little bush behind which they want to hide from legitimate criticism.

Democratic principles require that a central bank be transparent in its capacity as an instrumentality of government. If the RBZ is to maintain the confidence of the Zimbabweans, it is vitally important that it must be as transparent as any agency of government.

Furthermore, accountability raises questions about the role of the external auditors of the central bank. Given the alleged duplicitous role of some potential rogue elements within the RBZ, the question which arises relates to the assurance role of the external auditors.

From an audit viewpoint, what have they gleaned on the bond notes? The whole process from ordering to delivery of these bond notes. What internal controls and security mechanisms are there? One must bear in mind that any lapse on these poses a threat to the country's financial system.

One is not arguing for the RBZ to open up its debates on monetary policy to the public. In financial markets, any immediate disclosure of sensitive information can unsettle and destabilise the financial markets and result in adverse feedback loop. Notwithstanding this reality, a central bank needs to find ways and means of better disseminating information without destabilising the markets it seeks to serve.

Central banks need to change with the rapidly changing market conditions. They need to find and adopt newer and better ways and means of communication. Central banks need to understand and appreciate that they are under constant surveillance and are a subject of endless scrutiny. This is a characteristic of central banks everywhere.

Consequently, central banks need to adapt to changing circumstances in the global financial markets in general and their own immediate markets in particular.

Colls Ndlovu, an award-winning central banker, formerly with the South African Reserve Bank; was previously attached to the International Monetary Fund Institute, in Washington DC, where he completed an advanced programme in specialised financial institutions and derivative financial instruments in 2005. He writes in his personal capacity.

RBZ bond notes Zimdollar

All articles and letters published on Bulawayo24 have been independently written by members of Bulawayo24's community. The views of users published on Bulawayo24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Bulawayo24. Bulawayo24 editors also reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received.

Source: Colls Ndlovu


Latest News

Chamisa and Mnangagwa mourn Sri Lanka martyrs

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 641 Views

Multiple inconsistencies in Mr Multiverse Dungani's article. - I do no...

by Thulani Nkala | 21 April 2019 | 286 Views

'Biti and Welshman Ncube must not contest at congress'

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 1898 Views

Zanu-PF begins constitutional amendments - Zanu-PF has started the pro...

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 1409 Views

Rugare Gumbo snubs Mnangagwa & Zanu-PF

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 7494 Views

Chamisa clinches victory

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 6264 Views

White farmers told to pay ex-workers first - WHITE commercial farmers ...

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 1361 Views

'Foreign aid will not bail out Zimbabwe'

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 1622 Views

'Peasant farmers now driving Zimbabwe's economy' - THE agricultural se...

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 494 Views

192 Zimbabweans refused entry into South Africa - MORE than 107 000 pe...

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 2156 Views

Criminals cash in on lost IDs, certificates - CUNNING criminals are ea...

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 689 Views

Matebeleland Collective a ZANU PF and British creation?

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 888 Views

Dreaded CIO Minister in fresh mine wrangle storm

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 1578 Views

George Charamba gets baptism of fire

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 4409 Views

WATCH: Chiyangwa turns his 34 bedroom house into a hotel

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 3936 Views

President Mnangagwa's Easter message to Zimbabwe

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 1705 Views

'Mnangagwa and Enock Sithole were not crocodile gang members'

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 2957 Views

'Mnangagwa's advisor is a CIO double agent'

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 10409 Views

WATCH: Pastor kisses a woman to remove a demon - A video of a Pastor k...

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 4033 Views

Mujuru denies Mnangagwa's visit

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 April 2019 | 6189 Views

Valerio Sibanda's war time exploits

by Dr Milton, Chemhuru | 21 April 2019 | 6253 Views

Mohadi seeking to turn the tables on ex-wife

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 1992 Views

Chinamasa 'brushes off' sanctions mantra

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 2111 Views

Opposition will not observe ballot paper printing: Mangwana

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 2512 Views

Mnangagwa must apologise for his role in gukurahundi genocide

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 686 Views

Hailstorm kills one, displaces families - A hailstorm ravaged parts of...

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 539 Views

Serial rapist arrested - Police have arrested a 36-year-old man in the...

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 623 Views

Brooklyn bus inferno survivor wants compensation

by Staff reporter | 21 April 2019 | 647 Views


Charambas drop videos

by Staff reporter | 17 April 2019 | 1246 Views

Jah Prayzah dares UK fans

by Staff reporter | 17 April 2019 | 3469 Views

Bekezela wants his music to appeal to Zimbabweans - South Africa-based...

by Staff reporter | 17 April 2019 | 187 Views

Olinda and Tytan welcome new born baby

by newzimbabwe | 11 April 2019 | 896 Views

Bev looks to conquer world

by Staff reporter | 07 April 2019 | 2570 Views

Mkhululi Bhebhe puts Zimbabwe on gospel map

by Staff reporter | 06 April 2019 | 1808 Views

Winky D to receive award as ZimAchievers pay Tuku tribute

by Staff reporter | 05 April 2019 | 3268 Views

Mobile Spy Software Maker Mspy Hacked

mspy, the makers of a software-as-a-service product that claims to help more than two million people spy on the mobile devices of their kids and partners, to have been massively hacked. a public relations pitch from mspy to krebsonsecurity in march ... Read More
SecNews 17 May 2015 ago

Ios 9 Features Inspired By Android

apple announced ios 9 on monday, and while watching the keynote, i had just a little bit of déjà vu. most of ios 9's new features seem to be squarely aimed at apple's biggest rival in mobile: android. specifically, they were about catching up to ... Read More
Sergey 13 June 2015 ago